Software vs Hardware encoders: difference and which one to choose 

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
ceeblue software

What is an Encoder?

An encoder is either a device or a software application that changes data from one format to another. In video streaming, encoders are vital as they convert raw video footage into a compressed format, making it suitable for online transmission. 

This process ensures that videos can be streamed efficiently without losing quality, providing viewers with a smooth experience across different platforms and devices.

The Role of Encoders in Streaming

Encoders are essential for both live streaming and video-on-demand services:

  • They take raw video from cameras, game consoles, or other sources and convert it into a digital format for internet transmission. 
  • This conversion reduces the file size, making the video easier to stream and minimizing the required bandwidth. 

Encoders help deliver seamless video streams, regardless of the viewer’s internet speed.

Understanding Software Encoders

Software encoders are applications that run on a computer or server, using the CPU to process and encode video data. Examples of encoders include OBS Studio, XSplit, and vMix. 

These encoders offer a range of features and customization options, making them versatile tools for different streaming needs. Software encoders are widely used particularly in scenarios where flexibility and adaptability are the most important. 

They are especially beneficial for streamers who need to frequently update their encoding settings or integrate with various software tools and streaming platforms.

Overview of Software Encoders

Software encoders use the processing power of the computer they’re installed on to handle video and audio encoding. They are versatile tools that can manage various encoding tasks, whether it’s for live streaming or preparing video-on-demand content. 

One of the coolest and most valuable features about software encoders has to do with their flexibility, in the sense that they allow users to extensively customize encoding settings. Do you want a personalized streaming experience? That’s something software encoders can do. 

Advantages of Using Software Encoders

Software encoders offer several benefits:

  • Flexibility: easily updated with new features and improvements.
  • Cost-effectiveness: generally cheaper than hardware encoders as they use existing computer hardware.
  • Customizability: extensive settings for adjusting video quality, bitrate, and more.
  • Integration: seamlessly integrate with various streaming platforms and software tools.

These advantages make software encoders a popular choice for streamers needing a flexible and affordable solution.

Understanding Hardware Encoders

Hardware encoders are dedicated devices designed specifically for video encoding. They contain specialized chips that handle the encoding process, resulting in faster and more efficient performance. 

Examples of hardware encoders include products from brands like Videon, Osprey, Teradek, Blackmagic Design, and Matrox. These devices are often used in professional broadcasting environments where reliability and speed are paramount. 

Hardware encoders are particularly advantageous for users who need dedicated performance and do not want to rely on computer resources for encoding tasks.

Overview of Hardware Encoders

Hardware encoders are unique devices built to efficiently manage video and audio encoding. 

Unlike software encoders, which use a computer’s CPU to process tasks, hardware encoders have specialized chips dedicated solely to encoding

This specialization leads to quicker and more dependable performance. As a result, hardware encoders are perfect for professional settings and situations with high demands.

Advantages of Using Hardware Encoders

Hardware encoders have distinct benefits:

  • Performance: Superior encoding speed due to dedicated processing power.
  • Reliability: Consistent performance with minimal risk of crashes or slowdowns.
  • Quality: Often produce higher quality output with lower latency.
  • Efficiency: Free up computer resources as the device handles encoding.

These benefits make hardware encoders ideal for high-performance and reliable streaming, such as live sports broadcasting and large events.

Comparing Software and Hardware Encoders

When comparing software vs hardware encoders, several key factors must be considered to determine which is best for your specific needs. Both types of encoders have their own strengths and weaknesses, making them suitable for different use cases.

Performance and Speed

Hardware encoders generally outperform software encoders in terms of speed and reliability due to their dedicated processing power. Software encoders rely on the CPU, which can lead to variable performance based on the computer’s power. Here’s a comparison:

FeatureSoftware EncodersHardware Encoders
Encoding SpeedVariable, depends on CPUConsistently high
Resource UsageHigh, uses computer CPULow, dedicated processing unit
ReliabilityCan crash or slow downHighly reliable

Hardware encoders’ superior performance and reliability make them the preferred choice for professional applications where timing is critical.

Quality of Output

Both software vs hardware encoders can produce high-quality video, but hardware encoders typically have an edge due to their optimized processing capabilities. Software encoders offer more control over settings, allowing for fine-tuning to achieve the desired quality.

Flexibility and Scalability

Software encoders are highly flexible, easily updated, and customizable. They can be scaled by upgrading computer hardware. Hardware encoders, while efficient for specific tasks, are less flexible and harder to scale but excel in dedicated environments.

Cost Considerations

Cost is a major factor in choosing between software and hardware encoders. Software encoders are generally more affordable as they use existing hardware. Hardware encoders are more expensive but offer dedicated performance, justifying the cost for professional use.

Cost AspectSoftware EncodersHardware Encoders
Initial CostLow to moderateHigh
MaintenanceLow, can update softwareLow, replacement cost high
ScalabilityHigh, upgrade hardwareLimited, new devices needed

Considering these cost aspects helps in making an informed decision between software vs hardware encoders based on budget and performance needs.

Choosing the Right Encoder for Your Needs

Choosing between software and hardware encoders requires a thorough evaluation of your specific requirements, budget constraints, and the level of performance you need. Each type of encoder has unique strengths, so understand your priorities before making a decision.

Factors to Consider

When deciding between software vs hardware encoders, consider these factors:

  • Budget: determine your investment capacity.
  • Performance Needs: assess the required performance level for streaming.
  • Flexibility: consider how often you need to update or change settings.
  • Scalability: think about future needs and potential expansions.

These factors will help guide your decision and ensure that you select the encoder that best fits your streaming needs and long-term goals.

Use Cases for Software Encoders

Software encoders are ideal for:

  • Individual streamers: perfect for gamers, hobbyists, and small-scale streamers.
  • Flexible setups: suitable for scenarios requiring frequent updates and changes.
  • Cost-conscious users: great for those needing a budget-friendly solution.

These use cases highlight the versatility and accessibility of software encoders, making them a popular choice among various user groups.

Use Cases for Hardware Encoders

Hardware encoders are best for:

  • Professional broadcasters: essential for live TV, sports, and large events.
  • High-performance needs: required where encoding speed and reliability are critical.
  • Dedicated environments: ideal for setups demanding consistent performance.

These use cases underscore the reliability and high performance of hardware encoders, making them necessary in professional and demanding streaming environments.

Conclusion

Choosing between software vs hardware encoders depends on your needs, budget, and performance requirements. Software encoders offer flexibility and cost-effectiveness, suitable for many users. Hardware encoders provide unmatched performance and reliability, ideal for professional and high-demand applications. Understanding the differences and considering your unique needs will help you make the best choice for a great streaming experience.

Ceeblue is compatible with both software and hardware encoders. We have partnerships with a number of hardware providers and can provide on-prem solutions for customers with their own infrastructure.

GET YOUR FREE CEEBLUE ACCOUNT

ceeblue.net/free-trial/

EXPLORE THE CEEBLUE WEBRTC CLIENT SDK

Source Code
github.com/CeeblueTV/webrtc-client

Prebuilt NPM Package
npmjs.com/package/@ceeblue/webrtc-client

TRY OUT THE WEBRTC VIDEO.JS PLUGIN

github.com/CeeblueTV/videojs-plugins

Keep up to date with the latest from Ceeblue

More To Explore

How does HESP work?

What is HESP? The High-Efficiency Streaming Protocol (HESP) is an advanced technology designed for video streaming, ensuring ultra-low latency and

Read More »

Live Video Transcoding and Streaming in Under a Second. Really.

Follow Us

OFFICES

Netherlands

Germany

Spain

©2021 Ceeblue B.V. All Rights Reserved. Privacy & Cookies Policy